Theater, Dance, Comedy and Performance in Chicago (BETA)

Review: The Abduction From the Seraglio/Ravinia Festival

Opera, Opera Reviews No Comments »

RECOMMENDED

For the first decades of its existence, Ravinia was the summer opera capital of the United States and concert opera was a significant element of the 22-year music directorship of James Levine, who was also music director of the Metropolitan Opera. That tradition stopped under Christoph Eschenbach but has continued on under James Conlon, who is also music director of the Los Angeles Opera and the Cincinnati May Festival, where this semi-staged version of Mozart’s “The Abduction From the Seraglio” originated in 2006 conceived around Michael York narrating the spoken portions with a script by Marie Therese Squerciati that streamlines much of the action as well as wryly interpolates the proceedings for a modern audience with an Anglo sensibility that perfectly suits York’s narration. But make no mistake: it is the singing and the music that are the clear stars of this production, from Morris Robinson’s velvet-smooth deep bass and terrifying yet comical portrayal of the sadistic Osmin to Hanan Alattar’s stunning ease through the soprano stratosphere as Konstanze to James Conlon’s lively tempos and brilliant shaping of a chamber ensemble made up of non-vacationing Chicago Symphony members. What a rare treat it is to hear a Mozart opera in Ravinia’s Martin Theatre, with its 800-plus seats, close to the size of the theaters that Mozart had in mind when he wrote these works rather than the too large Harris Theater (Chicago Opera Theater) or the cavernous Civic Opera House (Lyric Opera) where nuance and subtlety are lost. The experience is nothing short of revelatory and long may this glorious tradition continue. But next time around, please, Ravinia, keep the standards consistent and hire a professional chorus, preferably members of the CSO’s own unparalleled ensemble rather than a volunteer chorus. For this work a chorus is only heard twice, but they are crucial and climactic moments that mar what precedes them, kind of like baking a cake from scratch and using canned frosting to top it off. (Dennis Polkow)

Mozart’s “The Abduction From the Seraglio” plays through August 16 at Ravinia’s Martin Theatre, Lake-Cook at Green Bay Rds., Highland Park, (847)266-5100.

Preview: Don Giovanni/Ravinia Festival

Opera No Comments »

Samuel RameyRECOMMENDED

Chicago Opera Theater had its say, now James Conlon and the Chicago Symphony have their turn at the work that many consider the most perfect of all operas. Ildebrando D’Arcangelo stars as the Don and longtime Giovanni of yesteryear and Chicagoan Samuel Ramey sings the role of his servant Leporello in these semi-staged Martin Theatre performances. Ramey, the most recorded bass in history who was so loyal to Lyric Opera and such a mainstay there for so many years that he moved to Chicago (it helped that he married a member of the chorus), is no longer engaged by Lyric now that he’s at the twilight of his long and wonderful career, but unlike his close friend and tenor Jerry Hadley, who was so despondent about roles drying up that he committed suicide last year, Ramey has taken a far more optimistic attitude and could well end up stealing the show from the Don as several notable Leporellos have done over the years. The woman seduced by the Don but faithfully cataloged in song by Leporello include Ellie Dehn as Donna Anna, Soile Isokoski as Donna Elvira and Heidi Grant Murphy as Zerlina. (Dennis Polkow)

At Ravinia Festival’s Martin Theatre, Lake-Cook & Green Bay Rds., Highland Park, 847)266-5100, 7pm August 15, 2pm August 17. $10-$75.

Review: Orlando/Chicago Opera Theater

Opera Reviews No Comments »

RECOMMENDED

In an effort to find suitable vehicles for superstar mezzo-soprano Marilyn Horne late in her career, Lyric Opera gave her a couple of male roles that in the eighteenth century were sung by superstar castratos, i.e., male singers whose testicles were removed before puberty to preserve a high voice but who developed an adult technique to propel their sound. (Talk about the high price of fame, but I digress.) One was Rossini’s “Tancredi,” the other was Handel’s “Orlando,” but both were jealous military conquerors, well, you get the general idea. That 1986 production also featured countertenor Jeffrey Gall and sopranos June Anderson and Gianna Rolandi (today Mrs. Sir Andrew Davis and director of Lyric’s Ryan Center) in a hopelessly mismatched vocal affair that left Handel the real loser. These days, it’s possible to assemble not one, but two countertenors for a production, as Chicago Opera Theater has done for its current production (Tim Mead and David Trudgen) and two sopranos who have range, power and even some eighteenth-century technique (Kate Mangiameli and Andriana Chuchman). The problem comes in when a seasoned Handel singer such as Mead who can sing trills and ornaments in an authentic style, shares the stage with cast members who simply do not have the vocal technique needed to sing this music. Twenty years ago, glossing over Handel’s rapid and florid passages like a car engine was deemed acceptable, but no longer. This is the kind of singing that gave Handel a bad reputation in modern times to begin with, and the music is not well served when the notes are blurred. Even so, there is much to recommend this production, especially director Justin Way’s film-noir conception, which at one point had Orlando choking an enemy in rhythm to his own trills and which manages to streamline the complex storyline. Raymond Leppard, one of the genre’s earliest early music pioneers, kept things moving along from the pit with grace and balance, and his own innovative harpsichord playing—sometimes augmented by organ along with the continuo—was some of the most original Handel accompaniment we have heard here. (Dennis Polkow)

At the Harris Theater for Music & Dance, 205 E. Randolph, (312)334-7777. This production is now closed.

Review: A Flowering Tree/Chicago Opera Theater

Opera Reviews No Comments »

RECOMMENDED

For those like myself who found “Doctor Atomic” an insufferably confused and convoluted enterprise, John Adams’ “A Flowering Tree” should be an effective antidote. Though its lacks the wit of a work such as “Nixon in China” or the gravitas of “Death of Klinghoffer,” Adams’ adaptation of an Indian folktale based on a translation by Indian scholar, poet and longtime University of Chicago professor A. K. Ramanujan has charms of its own, even if it sometimes takes political correctness to absurdities by, for instance, setting chorales of a work set in India in Spanish. The story is a rather static one, dealing with a young woman (Natasha Jouhl) who has the ability to transform herself to a tree and the prince (Noah Stewart) who falls in love with her, which isn’t helped by the presence of a storyteller (Sanford Sylvan) who has to explain things, but the music, particularly in the transformation scenes, is anything but static. Drawing heavily from Wagner’s “Ring” cycle, Adams’ music conveys magic and transformation using compact Wagnerian orchestration and Adams’ own effective leitmotivs, reminding us, for instance, of how many moments of Wagner could be interpreted as “Minimalist,” especially the prologue to “Das Rheingold” and the repeated arpeggios that represent the Rhine River. Though this Chicago Opera Theater production is obviously one of meager means, but unlike say, last year’s “Bluebeard’s Castle,” never looks cheap, which is no small accomplishment in these lean times. (Dennis Polkow)

At the Harris Theater for Music & Dance, 205 E. Randolph, (312)334-7777. This production is now closed.

Review: Don Giovanni/Chicago Opera Theater

Opera Reviews No Comments »

RECOMMENDED

When Don Giovanni goes to hell in the current Chicago Opera Theater production directed by Diane Paulus, it is a hell of scantily clad women overpowering him. Though this would probably be heaven to most men, it would seem especially so for Giovanni, who went after each and every woman that he met, to quote the potential future first-husband, “because I could.” But in case there was any doubt what happened to him, a bloody and decomposing Don is shown hanging from a meat-hook to Mozart’s life-affirming finale. Hm. Well, that doesn’t work, to be sure, but so much else does in this production that you won’t want to miss it. The concept is that Giovanni is a ruthless, gun-toting club owner (a precursor to “Phil Spector: The Musical” perhaps?) surrounded by ruthless women (Donna Elvira knees him in the groin at one point) in a colorful though very macabre world that for the most part brilliantly reflects the narcissism of the lead character. But Giovanni has to be a charmer, as well, and if the characters—and most importantly, the audience—don’t feel something for him, the true magic of the work gets lost in the shuffle. None of that matters much, though, when Mozart’s music is as fabulously served up as it is here. Conductor Jane Glover, one the great Mozart interpreters anywhere, keeps things lively and spirited in the pit at all times, and guides the young cast to heights and into a true ensemble where balance is, above all, the top priority. (Dennis Polkow)

At the Harris Theater for Music & Dance, 205 E. Randolph, (312)334-7777. This production is now closed.

Looking Ahead

Opera No Comments »

When it comes to opera in Chicago, opera-goers have two choices: go with the crowd over to big-budget Lyric Opera and its La Scala West repertoire centered on Italian operatic warhorses, or go with the opera cognoscente over to the smaller Chicago Opera Theater, the more innovative, discerning and adventurous of the two companies whose broader repertoire not only extends well beyond Lyric’s Italian base but spans the dawn of opera up through the twenty-first century.

From its inception thirty-four years ago, COT founder Alan Stone wanted to make sure that the company would not be perceived as a “little Lyric” but as a distinct company with its own identity and approach. Works that were too intimate for the cavernous Civic Opera House or that were either too old or too new for Lyric’s conservative subscriber base became the mainstay repertoire of COT and achieved such extraordinary success that late Lyric general manager Ardis Krainik tried some COT-inspired innovations, including the “Towards the 21st Century” initiative, which featured one contemporary American and contemporary European opera each season leading up to the new century, though Krainik’s successor William Mason ended up abandoning the program and now feels that Lyric’s seasons should have only two unknown (in Lyricspeak, unknown is synonymous with “unpopular,” which equals donor poison) operas out of eight per season, whatever century they may come from. While doing a Handel opera is conservative for Chicago Opera Theater, since Lyric has only discovered Handel in the last decade (unless you count such sideshows as Jon Vickers singing the oratorio “Samson” and Marilyn Horne singing “Orlando”), Handel repertoire is considered “new” and unfamiliar at Lyric.

                 And this year, though there bizarrely wasn’t a single Mozart opera to be heard all season long over at Lyric, COT is presenting the one Mozart opera to be heard in Chicago this year by opening its season this week with “Don Giovanni” (April 30-May 11) and further beats Lyric to the punch with the first ever live Chicago television broadcast of an opera free to Millennium Park’s Pritzker Pavilion at 7:30pm May 9. “‘Don Giovanni’ is the culmination of the triptych of the three Mozart-DaPonte operas that we inaugurated some years ago with the same creative team [conductor Jane Glover and director Diane Paulus], and something we are all looking forward to,” assesses COT general manager Brian Dickie. “The setting is a high-end New York nightclub where Don Giovanni is the proprietor and we hope that the broadcast will give a larger number of people a chance not only to see some great opera, but to see what this company is all about.”

True, Lyric did John Adams’ “Doctor Atomic” this season, but COT brought Adams’ most celebrated opera, “Nixon in China,” to Chicago two years earlier with a production that so impressed its composer that he agreed to come back to COT—not Lyric, mind you—to conduct the Chicago premiere of his latest work, “A Flowering Tree” (May 14-25), based on an Indian folktale which the composer describes as his own take on Mozart’s “The Magic Flute.” “John was enthusiastic with what the company did with ‘Nixon’ and audiences so embraced it that this seemed a natural follow-up,” Dickie says. “He wanted very much to conduct with us, but could only do the first two performances because he has another conducting engagement in Europe, but we have his very talented assistant coming in to do the remaining performances who knows the piece inside and out.”

And though Lyric did do Handel’s “Orlando” twenty years ago in a very stodgy and bombastic manner with Marilyn Horne sporting armor in a role written for a male castrato, this year’s COT production (May 28-June 8) will be the first performed by a countertenor (Tim Mead) that is giving attention to eighteenth-century performance practice with British conductor and early music specialist Raymond Leppard at the podium but with a contemporary update done in 1940s film-noir style.

The company’s thirty-fifth anniversary season has already been announced and the once-struggling COT looks to have a bright future ahead of itself, but Dickie is always looking ahead, even beyond the time that he will be running the company. “I’m 67,” says Dickie, “and there are so many opera voids in this town that I will not get a chance to fill, which will fall to my successor. And I’m still struggling with how to get all those core Lyric subscribers to try us out. Once they come, they subscribe, but getting them here is half the battle.” (Dennis Polkow)

Chicago Opera Theater’s season runs through June 8 at the Harris Theater, 205 East Randolph, (312)704-8414. 

Review: The Barber of Seville/Lyric Opera

Opera, Opera Reviews No Comments »

RECOMMENDED

One of the practical realities of the enormous expense of producing opera is that all productions—both the good and the bad—will pop up again. This can be a pleasure if a production was interesting and creative the first time around, but a real chore if not. The current Lyric Opera production of Rossini’s “The Barber of Seville” was first seen here nearly twenty years ago and has been revived every half a dozen years or so since, which means that if you enjoyed John Conklin’s free-floating red furniture across sky blue backgrounds with clouds the first time around, you’ll enjoy it again and again and again. If, however, you were left wondering what any of this had to do with “Barber of Seville” in the first place, your confusion is likely to multiply with each viewing. This revival was intended for Juan Diego Flórez, who wowed us in Rossini’s “Cinderella” two seasons ago and is the Rossini tenor of the moment, but who swallowed a fishbone in sunny Barcelona and somehow thought recovering there was preferable to doing so in a gray and cold Chicago in February. Go figure. Oh yes, and since the baritone set to play Bartolo was covering for another no-show who was set to sing the lead in “Falstaff,” there ended up being as many musical chairs in the casting as there are chairs left on the ceiling. With expectations that low, this is a “Barber” that despite coming up a few hairs short, is still a fun experience. Holding things together through all of these changes, Italian conductor Donato Renzetti keeps the orchestra flexible enough for all of the singing yet brisk and light at all times. And despite some vocal mismatches, everyone could be heard and blended as well as possible. Iowa tenor John Osborn may not have Flórez’ glorious timbre and flexible technique, but he does a solid job, especially in the masquerade scenes and grew more confident as the evening went on. Midwest mezzo-soprano Joyce DiDonato may not have the dark color that some of us prefer for Rosina but her vocal agility and her acting ability more than compensate. Those of us who have experienced Chicago baritone Philip Kraus’ trademark portrayal of Bartolo over the years at Chicago Opera Theater and his many comic performances at Light Opera Works—a company he founded and shepherded for a decade and a half before his own board unceremoniously dumped him—are delighted to see him singing and acting better than ever in a role that has truly become his own at his hometown opera company. (Dennis Polkow)

At the Civic Opera House, 20 N. Wacker, (312)332-2244. This production is now closed.

Bombs Away: Peter Sellars returns to Chicago

Opera No Comments »

By Dennis Polkow

“Does he still have the spiky hair?” asks a visitor who hasn’t seen director Peter Sellars in years. “Yes,” offers a Lyric Opera staffer, “and oddly enough, there is no mousse, no hairspray, it’s just—well, spiky.” Actually, as a now 50-year-old (but still boyish-looking) Sellars makes his way from the rehearsal stage, his hair looks like a surfeit of snakes standing at attention.

If opera is the domain of the director, there is no director more legendary and eccentric than Sellars, who not only revolutionized the genre with his bold, modern interpretations of the classics, but also by commissioning iconic new works as well that often touch deep social nerves. We haven’t seen Sellars in Chicago for nearly two decades—okay, he did direct a “Merchant of Venice” at Goodman back in 1994—but he sent shock waves throughout the opera world by staging “The Mikado” here on motorcycles in 1983 and then making “Tannhäuser” a disgraced televangelist in 1988. Sellers grins ear to ear when he is told that Lyric’s general director Bill Mason counts these daring and radical productions as among the finest that Lyric ever produced.    

Despite the fact that Sellars has been a constant collaborator with composer John Adams for more than two decades now, “Doctor Atomic” is the first Adams opera that Sellers is directing at Lyric Opera. Their inaugural 1987 “Nixon in China” was heard last year at Chicago Opera Theater and “El Nino” was heard at Ravinia, but “Doctor Atomic” is the first Adams opera ever presented at Lyric and the first production that Sellars has directed at the company since “Tannhäuser.”

Ironically, Adams was not an opera lover, nor even an opera goer, but Sellars told Adams that his music contained such drama that he simply “insisted” that Adams had to work in the form. “Nixon in China” was Sellars’ idea, as have been most of their collaborations. “Not ‘El Nino,’ ” Sellers is quick to point out. “A nativity play? No, that was a commission.”Adams came to Sellars, however, with “Doctor Atomic,” and Sellars was against it at first.

“As artists, we are not equipped to show Auschwitz, Hiroshima, Nagasaki,” Sellars says. “At a certain point, art trivializes things that are truly unspeakable and should not be aestheticized in any way. For me, what was therefore necessary was to draw very clear lines around what we did have the capability of showing and talking about and what we didn’t, and to have the humility in the face of the subject matter to confine ourselves to one twenty-four-hour period: the first atomic test on July 16, 1945.”

The genesis of “Atomic” is the San Francisco Opera asking Adams for a contribution to its 2005 “Faust” season of operas, with Robert Oppenheimer suggested as a modern Faust figure who sold his soul to create the first atomic bomb. “We set to work with Alice Goodman, who had written the librettos for ‘Nixon’ and ‘Klinghoffer,’” Sellars recalls, “and Alice is the person who said, ‘Actually, at the end of his life, Faust signed away and lost his immortal soul, whereas at the end of his life, Robert Oppenheimer realized that he had one.’” Ultimately, Sellars himself ended up writing the libretto, and he is flanked in his backstage office by dozens of books about physics and the bomb. “It’s not an accident that ‘Doctor Faustus’ was such a powerful image in the twentieth century, and we ended up honoring Christopher Marlowe and Thomas Mann with our play on their title. Mann’s novel was very important for the generation that created the bomb, and they were seeing themselves in those images. It really is a Greek tragedy, taking place across a single twenty-four-hour period. The audience walks in with Hiroshima, Nagasaki, the Cold War and nuclear accidents and cover-ups as the future that these men are bringing into the world.”

Sellars is clear that, for him, Oppenheimer begins heroically, “with the idea that the Nazis were going after the bomb and that our beating them to doing it was the only thing that could prevent them from taking over the world. But once Germany surrendered and we realized that there had been no German atomic program as such, we went ahead with the program anyway and unleashed it on civilian cities in Japan to establish ourselves as the world’s lone superpower. Did 350,000 people have to die to test our experiment?

“The fallout of this action is that right now, at this moment, in silos in Russia, there are nuclear warheads at hair-trigger alert, pointing at the city of Chicago.  Why?  We are not at war.  We need to complete the steps that Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev began in the back of a limo, of eliminating all of them.  It’s not a question of North Korea or Iran having them: there is no reason for any of them to exist, anywhere.  The toxins that have been released since 1945 means that cancer is the disease of choice and every one of us knows someone who is in chemotherapy right this minute.  Every one of us has Strontium-90 in our blood cells and bone marrow at this moment from atomic blasts; it is in our milk, our bones, it is throughout the world right now as we continue to be assured that such high levels of radioactivity are perfectly safe.”

He continues, “What is abundantly clear is that nobody can use these weapons. It’s no longer one nation versus another, you release a toxicity that creates a cloud that goes throughout the world. Henry Kissinger and George Schultz are currently at the forefront of the movement to eliminate these weapons. This is no longer conservative versus liberal. This is an issue for all of humanity. We have to eliminate seventy years of profoundly misguided policy and not carry it forward into the twenty-first century.”   

“Doctor Atomic” at the Civic Opera House, 20 North Wacker, (312)332-2244.